1. Traceability & Certification: “Can you provide a fully traceable, third-party verified Mill Test Report (MTR) that aligns with the specified international standard?”
-
Why This is Critical: This is your first and most important line of defense against material misgrading or substandard quality. An MTR (or MTC, Certificate of Conformity) is the material’s “birth certificate.” It must be traceable to the heat (melt) number and heat treatment batch on the actual pipe via stamped markings.
-
What to Look For:
-
Third-Party Verification: Does the MTR come directly from the mill (preferred), or is it from the supplier? Be wary of generic “batch” certificates.
-
Chemical Composition: Verify every element (Cr, Ni, Mo, C, N, etc.) against the required standard (e.g., ASTM A312 for seamless/welded pipe, A790 for duplex seamless). Pay close attention to key ratios like PREN (Pitting Resistance Equivalent Number) for corrosion-resistant grades.
-
Mechanical Properties: Confirm yield strength, tensile strength, and elongation meet the standard’s minimums.
-
Test Compliance: Ensure the required tests (e.g., hydrostatic, eddy current, ultrasonic, intergranular corrosion test) are listed and passed.
-
-
Red Flags: Vague certificates, refusal to provide MTRs upfront, MTRs that don’t match the stamped heat number on the material, values that are suspiciously “perfect” or exactly at the minimum requirement.
2. Technical Capability & Expertise: “What is your internal process for reviewing a technical project specification (e.g., ASTM/ASME, NACE MR0175, NORSOK M-650) and how do you ensure the material supplied meets these requirements?”
-
Why This is Critical: A order for “316L pipe” is not specific enough. You need to know they understand the application. Projects may require compliance with specific norms for offshore use (NORSOK), sour service (NACE), pressure vessel codes (ASME), or critical dimensions.
-
What to Look For:
-
Ask for Examples: Request case studies where they supplied material for a similar demanding application (e.g., subsea, pharmaceutical, chemical processing).
-
Quality Control Process: Have them walk you through their internal QC process. Do they perform their own PMI (Positive Material Identification) testing? Do they have in-house experts who can read and interpret complex project specs?
-
Non-Standard Requests: How do they handle requests for special testing (e.g., additional Charpy V-Notch impact tests at low temperature, IGC testing on extra coupons)?
-
-
Red Flags: The salesperson cannot answer technical questions and must “check with the factory.” They cannot explain the difference between common standards. They try to substitute a different grade without a formal request and engineering approval.
3. Logistics & Supply Chain Transparency: “Can you map your supply chain for me, from the original mill to your warehouse, and explain your process for preserving material identity and preventing contamination?”
-
Why This is Critical: The longest and most complex part of the journey is often from the mill to the supplier’s yard. You need to ensure the material is handled correctly to prevent damage, mixing of grades, and corrosion.
-
What to Look For:
-
Mill Relationship: Are they a direct authorized distributor for the mill, or are they buying from a trader? Buying from a trader adds another link and another risk.
-
Handling and Storage: Ask for photos of their warehouse. Is material stored indoors? Is carbon steel stored separately from stainless steel to prevent iron contamination (which can rust and破坏不锈钢的钝化层)? Are pipes capped to protect the ID?
-
Packaging: How is the material packaged for export? Proper wooden crates and seaworthy packaging are essential to prevent damage during ocean freight.
-
-
Red Flags: Evasive answers about their mill sources. Evidence of poor storage (outdoor yards, mixed materials). No clear procedures for material handling.
4. Commercial Integrity & Risk Mitigation: “What are the precise Incoterms for this shipment, and what guarantees do you provide against the material being held up in customs at the port of origin or destination?”
-
Why This is Critical: Hidden costs and logistical nightmares often arise from unclear Incoterms and customs issues. A low price per ton can be obliterated by unforeseen duties, port fees, and delays.
-
What to Look For:
-
Incoterms Clarity: Ensure you both understand who is responsible for freight, insurance, and customs clearance (e.g., FOB, CFR, DAP). Prefer terms that give you more control or clarity.
-
Export Compliance: The supplier is responsible for all export licenses and documentation in their country. They must guarantee the material can be legally exported.
-
Certificate of Origin: This document is critical for determining import duties. Ensure they provide it and that it’s accurate.
-
-
Red Flags: Unwillingness to take responsibility for export documentation. Vague answers about Incoterms. A price that seems “too good to be true” often means costs are hidden elsewhere.
5. After-Sales Support & Non-Conformance: “What is your formal process for handling a material non-conformance discovered upon arrival at our facility or during our own inspection?”
-
Why This is Critical: Things can go wrong. The true test of a supplier is not if problems never happen, but how they respond when they do.
-
What to Look For:
-
Clear Process: They should have a documented, straightforward process for raising a claim, including required evidence (photos, third-party inspection reports).
-
Financial Recourse: What is their commitment? Full replacement? Credit? Who bears the cost of return shipping?
-
Proactive Communication: A good supplier will want to know immediately and will work with you to find a root cause and solution.
-
-
Red Flags: Vagueness about their claims process. Defensive language. No history of successful claim resolution.
Your Audit Action Plan:
-
Document Request: Before the audit, send a formal request for their company quality manual, certification (e.g., ISO 9001), and sample MTRs and packing lists.
-
Virtual/On-Site Tour: Insist on a video call or, for critical projects, a site visit to their warehouse and processing facilities.
-
Third-Party Inspection: For your first order or any large project, mandate a pre-shipment inspection by a respected third-party agency (e.g., SGS, Bureau Veritas, TÜV) to verify quantity, quality, markings, and documentation before the material leaves their facility. The cost is insignificant compared to the risk.
